Tomato Pie Cafe

Spelling Chmap a month ago

Really liked it here. Plenty of seating inside and out. The outside seating appeared to be pet-friendly, which we love. Delicious tomato pie (I had the version with corn and bacon)....it was truly excellent. Our server was very friendly and attentive, and it didn't take long for our order despite being fairly busy. Next time we're in Lititz we'll definitely stop in again I saw plenty of things on the menu that I'd like to try.

Nicole Solis 3 months ago

I can’t believe I’ve never had tomato pie before, but trying it here for the first time was an absolute game-changer. It was absolutely divine — perfectly savory, rich, and flavorful! My partner got a sandwich and salad, and he loved his meal just as much. The entire experience was fantastic from start to finish. Incredible food, great atmosphere, and wonderful service. We will definitely be back next time we are in the area!

Zach Xue 6 months ago

For our visit to Lititz, Pennsylvania, we decided to visit the famous Tomato Pie Cafe for breakfast. The interior and exterior are very purposefully designed with lots of greenery and homely atmosphere. We got seated immediately with a table near the window and placed our orders shortly after. The food came out very fast and honestly, some of the best breakfast food I've had in a long time. I ordered the tomato pie flipper with chia pudding and two slices of heavily buttered sourdough. The omelet itself was perfectly seasoned, given a generous portion of cheese, and fluffy to the bite. The chia pudding also really blew me away, I didn't expect it to basically be a better tasting yogurt. Overall, a great experience. If you're ever in the area, I would highly recommend.

English Bully 10 months ago

We were here on a weekday for lunch and somehow lucked into one of the best tables in the place- front left high top- with a beautiful view of the park and old Wilbur chocolate factory. I ordered the hot roast beef and hubby ordered the tomato pie. I loved my dish, but after tasting the tomato pie, I will never order anything else but that. It was melt in your mouth delicious! Do not miss it!! The greens that come with your meal are so tasty with the lemon white balsamic from Olio down the street. We also ordered a pumpkin macchiato, so good. Can’t wait to check out their other seasonal drinks throughout the year, I’m sure they’re all as unique and tasty.

Victor “Bud” Nye a year ago

One of my wife and my favorite breakfast spots when we vacation in Lititz. The vibe is super cool and laid back, it’s really nice inside and the staff are always great here. On our stay this last week I’ve had the pancakes which were great, the sausage egg wrap which was nice, and the classic breakfast which was great as well. The bacon is also done perfectly the two times I ordered it. My wife generally gets the classic breakfast as well, and for the first time tried the squash side and absolutely loved it, it’s baked, then tossed on the griddle with a little bit of sugar. She also loves the tea here over anywhere else in town.